OpenDesktop.org
5 星中有 2.3 星 ( 根據 3 場評價 )
關於:
自由雲端服務。 Opendesktop.org 係一個自由平台，為任何重視自由同開放嘅人提供免費嘅雲端儲存、網上辦公室編輯、聯絡人同日曆工具、個人聊天同訊息，同埋項目開發同產品發佈。開放式桌面 . org 唔會賣你嘅數據。免費攞個帳戶，享受所有服務嘅真正自由：產品、項目、檔案、日曆、聯絡人、直接訊息、音樂、即時通訊、論壇、地圖、社交。你得到嘅嘢：（1）保護你嘅私隱：最先進嘅端對端加密確保私人通訊保持私隱； （2）所有嘢都喺你手頭上：註冊一個帳戶，將所有嘢集中喺一個地方； （3）保持所有嘢同步：用 CardDAV 、 CalDAV 、 WebDAV 將你嘅數據同步到你最鍾意嘅應用程式、裝置同平台。
提供:
31/05/2020
我會講以下嘅嘢：
1. 佢哋的確會用 google 分析同 newrelic （呢個可能係嚟自第三方外掛程式/外掛程式）。好多網站都會用呢啲，或者至少係 Google 分析，嚟追蹤佢哋嘅訪客（有時唔係為咗獲利）。所以我會畀3分佢。
2. Using Google Captcha can, at times, be necessary since it is perhaps the best anti-spam protection. They use it to get rid of spam. It is true that Google collects data about users through this, so I’d give them just 4 blocks for this since I find this as necessary to use at times.
3.5GB Nextcloud 限制係正常嘅，因為你唔可以免費畀無限儲存空間。我只會視呢個為交易，如果佢哋會要求貨幣或者其他嘢，以便一係攞到呢個，一係就擴大儲存空間。但係佢哋好似畀5Gb任何人係免貿易。
4. 連結去社交網絡，例如 facebook 或者 twitter 係因為各種原因而有問題，所以我會為咗呢個目的而畀4個區塊佢哋，但係我唔會覺得係好大問題，尤其係當你簡單咁連結去呢啲而唔用佢哋包含追蹤器嘅掣嘅時候。
5. 喺維基 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenDesktop.org # 歷史我發現擁有佢哋嘅公司係呢間 https://en.
整體嚟講，我會認為呢個係一般嚟講係冇貿易嘅。當然有警告。
31/05/2020
Well that’s a tricky one. On the website they use google analytics and have ads for their facebook and twitter account. These networks are trade-based. I registered an account and I had to verify to google that I’m not a robot via reCAPTCHA – google uses that of course to collect data about you so that’s another trade. After I verified my email I have access now to surprisingly a lot of services like files, calendar, maps (using openstreetmap.org) etc. – however privacy badger shows me a tracker called “cdn.pling.com” and “www.pling.com” and uBlock origin blocked “newrelic.com”. “New Relic is a San Francisco, California-based technology company which develops cloud-based software to help website and application owners track the performances of their services.” (https://www.wikiwand.com/en/New_Relic#/Products) It says to help track the performances of their servies, but I won’t trust them, because if you dig into they privacy policy, you will figure out they collect a shit ton of data about you and share it with 3rd parties and such: https://newrelic.com/termsandconditions/privacy New Relic is also a big corporation with a revenue of around 600 million dollar (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Relic)
pling.com 係 opendesktop.org 服務嘅一部分，亦都有谷歌分析同新嘅遺物，所以佢亦都會收集數據。
我哋繼續用 opendesktop . org ：當我撳一下其中一個服務，例如「檔案」，一個 nextcloud 標籤就會打開，而我用相同嘅用戶名同密碼登入之後，我就可以存取呢啲服務，而且佢哋似乎係免費嘅，因為冇追蹤器或者廣告。但係我有有限嘅儲存空間，即係5 gb 。 「社交」打開咗冇貿易嘅 Mastodon ，「項目」打開咗好似係冇貿易嘅 opencode.net —— 所以所有呢啲服務都係冇貿易嘅。佢哋冇提供任何高級或付費帳戶，但係儲存空間只係限於 5 gb – 我唔知你可唔可以增加，同埋你係咪要做啲嘢先可以做到。
所以正面嚟講，你可以存取一堆服務，但係負面嚟講，你要交易你嘅數據先可以去到嗰度使用佢哋。
Framasoft （ https://www.directory.trade-free.org/goods-services/framasoft/）似乎亦都會喺佢哋嘅網站上面為你提供相同嘅服務，而且佢哋仲會向你展示點樣安裝 nextcloud ： https ：
總括嚟講，我傾向用數據收集嘅論點去認為佢哋唔係冇貿易嘅。佢哋可以移除 Google 分析，因為佢只係用嚟收集有關用戶嘅數據。佢哋亦都可以將啲廣告移除去 Facebook 同 Twitter 。同埋關於嗰個 newrelic.com 追蹤器 – 亦都係陰暗嘅。而如果 opendesktop.org 嘅創辦人 Karl Karlitscheck 話「私隱係民主嘅基礎」，同埋人哋應該有「喺互聯網時代控制自己嘅數據」嘅基本權利。 – 噉佢唔應該用谷歌分析。
最後，我搵到 opendesktop.org 背後嘅公司，叫做 hive01：「 h i v e 01係一間互聯網營銷專家，專注於互聯網廣告作為銷售、分銷同推廣商品同服務嘅手段。我哋有幾年嘅互聯網營銷經驗。我哋嘅網上活動、文字連結廣告同搜尋引擎優化服務係你成功嘅互聯網營銷策略嘅基石。」 http : / / 蜂巢01. com / 廣告 /
總括嚟講：如果我哋想有個目錄，盡量免貿易，我唔會加入 opendesktop . org – 有其他方法，例如 framasoft 。你對開放桌面 . org 有咩睇法？