99的力量
一家网页设计公司在 Freevolution 礼品经济计划中完全免费提供服务 - 一种称为 FREE PASS 的非强制性预付计划。因为展示自己不应该花费你任何费用。
It is a very difficult service to rate for several reasons. One is their “pricing” model. For one, a price is mainly (if not only) connected to trade, else the notion of “price” won’t even exist. Second, in order to get their services you have to either pay what you want (so yes, a trade), or they will give you a “free pass” card https://www.directory.trade-free.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/PYv5pmU.png. What if you do not want any of that? And you simply want their services but do not care about the free pass or do not want to pay them anything? Can you do that? Why isn’t there a way to just access the services without any conditions?
其次,他们提供多种看似完全无关的服务:网页设计(托管、编程、设计、营销);咨询(指导、解决问题、业务策略);讲故事(快乐、抑郁、焦虑、成功)。这些服务仅通过电子邮件等私人方式提供。我们无法检查其中任何一个。
我个人认为,如果他们依赖上面解释的某些交易,这会造成权力的不平衡和不良的激励。如果付费的人优先于不付费的人怎么办?我不相信任何此类计划,因为我无数次看到它们如何导致不良结果。在我看来,这不是一种无贸易服务,因为它们确实允许一些自愿交易,这些交易最终会影响他们的优先事项,其次我们甚至无法检查他们提供的服务是否是无贸易的,因为所有这些都是通过电子邮件等私人方式完成的。
如果他们想提供网页设计教程或帮助,他们可以制作相关视频并在 archive.org 或类似的无贸易服务上免费在线发布,或者如果他们想提供各种“谈话”服务,例如讨论和咨询,他们应该这样做,而不是向人们发送免费通行卡或要求他们支付他们想要的费用。他们只会提供这些,如果他们需要经济帮助,他们只会要求捐款,无论您是否要求他们提供服务,这些捐款都是自愿捐款。
W.A.I.T. – What Am I Trading? Well, it’s a bit confusing, since the website asks you to pay either nothing or pay what you want (https://99power.org/pricing). I find this in contrast to offer something without asking anything in return and relying on donations with a donation page, where you can donate if you want. What if the website gets 5 e-mails about using the service and 2 of those use the pay nothing option and 3 of those use the pay what you want option. Will everyone get the same service? What if one of those 3 who pay something pays 10€, the other one 50€ and the third one 300€? Will the one with 300€ get a better or faster service? I think that could be a slippery slope.
另一件让我困惑的事情是提供“商业建议”(https://99power.org/about – https://www.directory.trade-free.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/sPf4mPn.png)。这也与无贸易理念形成鲜明对比,因为商业就是贸易游戏。但如果提供的商业建议是无贸易的,那么它就是一种无贸易的服务。类似于提供一本免贸易的圣经,尽管圣经是胡说八道且不科学的。
因此我不知道该怎么处理这个。我想说,如果他们想提供“网页设计、编码、编程、商业建议和一般咨询”作为无贸易服务,他们应该提供这些服务并创建一个接受捐赠的页面,仅此而已。没有混乱,没有废话——只有无贸易的服务。
我还想在底部的网站上提及基于贸易的网络(https://www.directory.trade-free.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/dzPEBnr.png)。但网站上似乎没有追踪器。
现在我会给出 5 个区块中的 3 个,我希望其他人对此发表评论以了解他们的论点。